A tactical vote for the Left!

 Screen Shot 2014-04-14 at 11.51.01 AM

I’m not about to start doing my Woolworths dinner shopping in a red beret, nor am I yet comfortable calling my barman “fighter” when I’ve just purchased a R50 craft beer, but I’m still going to vote EFF come May 7.

Let me explain why.

I believe the ANC has the structures and legitimacy to govern South Africa. This comes from 20 years in government and 82 years of struggle. The DA might believe they have the capacity to rule, but their legitimacy is in dispute. Their election manifesto mentions apartheid 12 times, while the ANC’s manifesto only drops the A-bomb eight times.

The DA are at pains to tell how their members opposed that system of institutionalized exploitation, and today they are still determined to redress the “economic legacy of apartheid” by growing the economy and creating jobs.

I’m inclined to place SA’s struggle in the context of the ongoing global class wars between heinously affluent, yacht-owning, car-collecting industrialist-financiers and the rest of us.

From that perspective, it’s the very economic system itself that’s responsible for the exploitation of workers – capitalism. Apartheid was the implementation method used here for 45-odd years. After that fell, the capitalist mavens co-opted some liberators and changed their system of wealth extraction to market fundamentalism, deregulation, BEE, trickle-down economics and the mantra of growth for job creation.

In 2008, 48 percent of South Africans lived below the poverty line of R524 a month. Trickle-down economics hasn’t worked.

I believe the only way to ensure a humane, worker-friendly, pro-poor country is to have a government that creates it with laws. We need a strong, activist government prepared to make fundamental, progressive policies – yes, socialist ones – that put the more rapacious exploitation of big business in check.

This means placing more of the country’s assets in the hands of the people, giving workers a reasonable living wage and a say in the way their company is run.

The party that has reopened the debate on economic transformation along these lines is EFF.

They have shown marketing genius and placed the economic system front and centre in the party-political debate.

Sure, the ANC is likely to win another national election by miles, and I wouldn’t have it any other way. They’re the only party with enough national buy-in to ensure we keep chugging along fairly intact as a country.

But the ANC needs to be aware of a groundswell of popular discontent with their market-friendly policies. These have led to massive poverty, corrupt self-enrichment by many of its leaders, an unforgivable massacre of 34 miners in Marikana – all to protect the interests of monopoly capital and the disintegrating Tripartite Alliance.

Every day, protestors across the country risk their lives to voice their discontent at the government, the ANC. They’re not asking for Big Business to come and save them. They’re demanding that the state supply them with social services, quality government and jobs that pay a living wage.

This requires state action. A vote for the EFF is a vote for a self-described “Marxist-Leninist, Fanonian organization…” which believes only a socialist transformation “will end the suffering of our people”.

The South African political spectrum has been bereft of a meaningful, independent left for decades. With the DA as official parliamentary opposition, the ANC’s main challenger has been a business-friendly party of the centre-right.

No wonder the ANC’s manifesto also speaks of “inclusive growth and job creation”. The ANC is the party of the R30bn arms deal, and other outrages perpetrated in the name of job creation.

But all is not lost. The ANC also purports to be braced for the second phase of the struggle, when they “implement radical socio-economic transformation to meaningfully address poverty…”

Their manifesto is full of exciting plans for pro-poor projects – homes, 1 000 schools, three universities, 43 hospitals. That is the kind of positive intervention that only a Government can make. And if their main rivals are perceived to be the stridently interventionist EFF, the ANC is more likely to make it.

So I say, vote EFF, and pull the ANC left. If EFF can garner a significant slice of the vote, ANC will be forced to take their sentiments seriously, and the ANC’s socialists will gain influence.

This is not to say the EFF is ready to govern. And sure, some of their policy proposals read like a brainstorm that got out of hand when the beer arrived. (Let’s build some new cities!)

But the party expresses a profound, worldwide popular dissatisfaction with the current economic system. It is a feeling manifesting in Greece, Spain, Egypt, Brazil and elsewhere. These protestors are asking for more than just a job, any job. Students want university admission, mothers want better healthcare, people want easier access to cities and the internet.

People want the government to redirect the obvious profits earned and stashed by a handful of industrialists and financiers and put them to work improving society.

Only a government can do that. The ANC will govern. But they need to be encouraged to follow through on their pro-poor traditions. And I think my vote for the EFF will help give them that encouragement.

This story first appeared in the Mail & Guardian.


Writer for television, print and digital, corporate and editorial. Editor and writer of books. Musical performance, spoken word as Inspector Ras. Guitar/vocals for The Near Misses, (Worst Band In JoburgTM). The last whitey at umsebenzi. Latest book 415 Action-Packed Neighbourhood Marketing Tips with Basil O'Hagan, out now. @hagenengler

(2) Comments

  1. I think any vote other than the ANC will help SA move towards a more diversified, or at least heterogenous, and therefore mature democracy. That’s why I voted for Cope in the last election. But remember what happened to Cope after the last election: there was a minor meltdown as the party\’s structures came to terms with the prospect of five years of irrelevance. I think there will be a similar shakeup in the EFF after the election, which is not necessarily a bad thing. It’s a reality check.

    I’m not so sure that the ANC is this pro-free market organisation that you seem to think it is. If anything, it is quite left-leaning. But that is just a matter of perspective, I guess.

    • Ami, I agree with you in many ways. My vote for a party is like the kiss of death. I have already voted for UDM, ID and Cope. So if I were EFF I’d be a bit concerned about getting my vote. It’s also true that ANC is left-leaning. But the party is a scene of ideological struggle. During the Marikana massacre, the capitalists clearly gained the upper hand. So my EFF punt is an attempt to give the ANC’s socialists – of which there are many – a boost. If they perceive the threat to be coming from the left, they will move that way…

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.

Please type the characters of this captcha image in the input box

Please type the characters of this captcha image in the input box